A few more thoughts on the mess at WVU:
President Mike Garrison says he has no plans to resign after his top lieutenants awarded a degree to Gov. Joe Manchin's daughter despite the fact she had no proof she earned it. And official records might have been altered to justify awarding that degree.
The
headline in this morning's The Herald-Dispatch said, "WVU Board of Governors standing behind president." If I were Garrison, I would make sure none of the people standing people have a knife in their hands. The board is likely composed of political appointments. Garrison himself was a political appointment. Protecting your own, of course. But someday the board may decide to throw Garrison overboard. I make no pretense of knowing how the internal politics of the WVU BOG works. But I don't see how Garrison can hold out forever, even if he is high on Gov. Joe Manchin's BFF list.
We're seeing the anti-Garrison factions and the pro-Garrison factions align. The fact is that something very, very bad happened on Garrison's watch. It was committed by his top advisers. No reasonable person can expect that Garrison knew nothing of what happened. It's time for him to go.
Perhaps the WVU BOG feels the same way and is coming up with a cover story. And that process is taking longer than expected. I don't know. I only know West Virginia's "flagship" university is in a state of dishonor.
###
For years, the job of university president has morphed from one of top scholar who keeps the place running to top cheerleader who can keep the money flowing in. Throw in West Virginia's habit of turning everything into a patronage job, and the degree flap at WVU was inevitable.
Will we learn anything from this episode? Are you kidding?
The ones who might actually be learning something are the kids in the public relations classes at WVU. They're learning how to not handle a disaster.
It reminds me of January 1988, when that big diesel fuel tank ruptured at Floreffe, Pa. Hundreds of thousands of gallons of diesel fuel poured into the Monongahela River and from there into the Ohio. The tank was owned by Ashland Oil Inc., which immediately took responsibility and paid for all cleanup and mitigation costs. That was how to handle a disaster. Garrison provides WVU students with a textbook case from the other end of the spectrum.
###
A few years ago, Marshall University was looking for a president. Its BOG appointed one of its own members to be interim president with the understanding he would not seek the job permanently. But once in office, he decided he liked the job. He had good ideas and he was a good ambassador for the university, but he wasn't an academic. He was a well-connected lawyer.
Ultimately the MU BOG did the right thing and brought in an experienced university administrator to be president.
This is in no way suggesting the man who would have been president would have done something as foolish as what the WVU administration did, but having a real university administrator in the top job, not a well-connected lawyer, provides several layers of defense against pressures to do something that corrupt.
###
Of all people, the one person who needs to come clean is Joe Manchin. He can't continue to cast his daughter as the victim in this. That insults everyone who knows what happened.
But will the governor tell everyone what his role was in this? If he was involved, can he stonewall until after the general election?
Manchin has lot a lot of goodwill in this. Can he recover it?